Copycat Carrabba’s Chicken Marsala: The 30-Minute Restaurant Favorite You Can Make at Home

Carrabba’s Chicken Marsala is a restaurant favorite for good reason: tender chicken, earthy mushrooms and a silky wine-and-cream sauce. This Editors’ Pick on Food.com shows how to get close at home in about half an hour. More than 140 home cooks have reviewed it, and many say it saves them a restaurant bill.

Recipe at a Glance

Ready in30 minutes
Ingredients7
Serves4
MethodOne skillet, stovetop
Serve withButtered fettuccine
BadgeEditors’ Pick

Why This Copycat Works

Browned butter, shallots and mushrooms build the base. Dry Marsala wine adds a nutty sweetness, heavy cream turns it into a velvety sauce and a squeeze of lemon brightens everything. One reviewer who compared several versions said the lemon “knocked this baby up a few notches.”

Note that Marie, the Food.com member who shared it, said she hadn’t tried it herself when she posted. Hundreds of reviews have since made up for that.

Ingredients

  • 4 tablespoons butter, divided
  • 4 boneless, skinless chicken breast halves
  • 4 shallots, finely chopped
  • ½ lb mushrooms, sliced
  • ¼ cup dry Marsala wine
  • ½ cup heavy cream
  • 1 teaspoon lemon juice
  • Salt and pepper
  • Fettuccine (the recipe says to serve with buttered fettuccine)

What Is Marsala Wine?

A reader asked, so here’s the short answer: Marsala is a fortified Italian wine. For savory dishes like this one, buy dry Marsala, since sweet versions can taste syrupy. Look for it in the wine aisle or the cooking wine section.

How to Make It

  1. Flatten the chicken. Pound the breasts to an even thickness and season lightly with salt and pepper.
  2. Sear. Melt 2 tablespoons of butter in a large skillet and brown the chicken about 2 minutes per side.
  3. Set aside. Move the chicken to a plate.
  4. Cook the vegetables. Melt the remaining butter and cook the shallots and mushrooms until the mushrooms brown lightly.
  5. Add the wine. Pour in the Marsala, bring to a boil and scrape up the browned bits.
  6. Add cream and lemon. Stir in both and bring back to a boil.
  7. Season. Add salt and pepper to taste.
  8. Finish the chicken. Return it to the pan for about 3 minutes to reheat and finish cooking.
  9. Serve. Spoon over buttered fettuccine.

Tips for a Better Sauce

  • Use real heavy cream. One fan says anything else will curdle. Another cook used half-and-half, saw it curdle and found it cooked out as the sauce reduced.
  • Don’t skip the lemon. Several reviewers call it essential.
  • Reduce the Marsala. Too much wine can taste harsh, so let it cook down.
  • Need more sauce? Several reviewers say the recipe doesn’t make much. One doubles the Marsala and uses 1½ times the cream. Another triples the liquid ingredients.
  • Check the chicken. USDA guidance calls for 165°F in the thickest part.

Reader-Approved Tweaks

  • Toss the pasta in the sauce. One cook sautéed the noodles in some of the Marsala sauce and said it tasted just like the restaurant.
  • Season the chicken more. A few reviewers add oregano, thyme or marjoram, and one used an Italian seasoning blend.
  • Add pancetta or prosciutto. Several fans of the restaurant version say a little cured pork brings the dish closer to the original.
  • Grill the chicken. Another reviewer swears grilling, not pan-searing, gets the restaurant’s smoky flavor.
  • Swap in other mushrooms. One cook used wild mushrooms and loved it.
  • Use onion, garlic or Parmesan. A baker substituted minced onion for shallots and added garlic and Parmesan.
  • Add depth. A splash of Worcestershire or red cooking wine also had fans.

Honest Reader Feedback

Not everyone calls it an exact clone. One reviewer says it lacks the grilled flavor and seasoning of the restaurant dish. If you want a true copy, try the tweaks above. If you want a quick, tasty Marsala, the original recipe delivers.

Common Questions From Home Cooks

Can I use chicken thighs? A reader asked, and the recipe doesn’t say.

Does it include pasta? The method says to serve with buttered fettuccine, but there’s no pasta in the ingredient list.

Is a shallot the green part? No. A shallot is a small bulb related to onions, and you chop the bulb.

Source: Food.com

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top