Panera’s Cream Cheese Potato Soup: The 6-Ingredient Copycat That Tastes Like a Bread Bowl Without the Bread

Some soups warm you up better than a sweater. This copycat of the cream cheese potato soup once served at St. Louis Bread Company, better known as Panera, has more than 780 reviews on Food.com and a Community Pick badge. The submitter calls it her favorite potato soup recipe, and the method is as easy as boiling, mashing and melting.

Recipe at a Glance

Ready in1 hour
Ingredients6
Serves4 to 6
MethodOne pot, stovetop
StyleCopycat of Panera’s (St. Louis Bread Company) potato soup

Why This Soup Is So Creamy

Cream cheese does the heavy lifting. Instead of flour or heavy cream, the soup melts a block of cream cheese into chicken broth and tender potatoes. Mashing a few potatoes releases their starch and thickens the base naturally. A pinch of white pepper and ground red pepper adds a gentle kick that keeps the soup from tasting flat.

Ingredients

  • 4 cups chicken broth
  • 4 cups peeled, cubed potatoes
  • ½ teaspoon seasoning salt
  • ¼ teaspoon white pepper
  • ¼ teaspoon ground red pepper
  • 1 (8-ounce) package cream cheese, cut into chunks

How to Make It

  1. Combine the base. Add the broth, potatoes and spices to a pot.
  2. Boil. Cook over medium heat until the potatoes turn tender.
  3. Mash a few. Smash some of the potatoes against the pot to release starch for thickening.
  4. Lower the heat. Drop the temperature to low.
  5. Add the cream cheese. Drop in the chunks.
  6. Melt and stir. Heat, stirring often, until the cheese melts completely.

Why Some Cream Cheese Won’t Melt, and How to Fix It

This is the most common complaint in the recipe’s questions and reviews. Cream cheese can clump or curdle if it hits the soup cold or boils too hard. Readers recommend these fixes:

  • Soften it first. Let the cream cheese come to room temperature before adding.
  • Press it through a strainer. One baker mashed it through a wire strainer so it dissolved easily.
  • Blend it. Another cook blended the cream cheese with a little broth before stirring it in.
  • Keep the heat low. Gentle heat helps it melt smoothly.
  • Keep stirring. It also prevents a skin from forming on top.

Reader-Approved Tweaks

The recipe as written is simple, but many home cooks add flavor:

  • Add aromatics. The recipe lists no onion or garlic, so bakers often slowly sauté diced onion and garlic in butter first.
  • Use baked potatoes. One cook microwaved potatoes with the skin on, then peeled and cubed them. She says they stay firmer and taste better than boiled ones.
  • Keep the skins. Red potatoes work well unpeeled.
  • Top it. Crispy bacon, shredded cheddar, green onions or sour cream are popular.
  • Swap in cream. One baker replaced a cup of broth with heavy cream.
  • Go heartier. Add an extra potato or two for a chunkier soup.

Common Questions From Home Cooks

What potatoes work best? The recipe doesn’t specify. Several readers suggest starchy varieties like russets, and red potatoes also earned praise.

Can I make it ahead? A reader asked, but the recipe itself doesn’t say.

Why isn’t there onion in the recipe? Other readers noticed too. Some say earlier versions included diced onion, so add it if you like.

What to Serve With It

Pair the soup with cornbread, a crusty loaf or a simple salad. For an extra Panera feel, serve it in a hollowed-out bread bowl or baked potato skin.

Source: Food.com

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top